The great Russian novelist Leo Tolstoy spent his life capturing the vastness of human experience. He gave the world literary masterpieces such as War and Peace and Anna Karenina. Yet, as his hair turned grey and his focus shifted toward a primitive Christian philosophy, he turned his powerful gaze inward. The man who had spent decades chronicling the lives of emperors and peasants began to question the very food on his plate.
His journey toward a compassionate life was a slow and painstaking climb. The biographer William Shirer observed that Tolstoy gradually surrendered his worldly vices, giving up hunting, smoking, and drinking. But his final transition proved to be his most challenging spiritual hurdle. Vegetarianism was the most difficult virtue to acquire. It demanded a complete confrontation with deeply ingrained cultural habits. Once he crossed that threshold, his circle of compassion expanded to oppose all forms of animal cruelty, including the practice of vivisection. He believed that if society accepted the right to endanger the lives of the helpless for the benefit of the many, there would be no limit to human cruelty.
In 1892, Tolstoy published his primary vegetarian manifesto as an introduction to Howard Williams’s book, The Ethics of Diet. He titled his essay The First Step. In its pages, Tolstoy recounted the profound hesitation he felt when deciding to witness the reality of meat production. He wanted to visit a slaughterhouse in the city of Tula. Yet, shame held him back. It was the natural embarrassment of watching a tragedy that one knows is about to happen but has no power to prevent.
While delaying his visit, Tolstoy gathered stories from the people he met along the Russian roads. On one journey, he encountered a young butcher returning home. The young man admitted that his job was to stab the animals. When Tolstoy suggested that eating meat was merely a luxury rather than a necessity, the young butcher agreed. He confessed that he felt genuine pity for the creatures, recalling how his own father had never even killed a chicken. Another retired soldier turned butcher expressed a similar sorrow. He wept for the quiet, tame cattle that came to the slaughterhouse with trust in their eyes.
The raw reality of animal suffering struck Tolstoy most vividly during a walk from Moscow. He accepted a lift from some carters on the Thursday before Easter. As they entered a village, they witnessed a pink pig being dragged from a yard. It shrieked with a sound that resembled a human scream. A man gashed its throat. The wounded animal broke free, running through the dirt covered in blood. Tolstoy watched closely. The men eventually captured the pig again to finish the deed. When the squealing stopped, the rough, hard-drinking carter sitting beside Tolstoy sighed heavily. He asked whether men would have to answer for such actions.
That sigh revealed a universal truth to Tolstoy. He believed that human beings possess a natural aversion to killing. Unfortunately, society systematically erases this instinct through habit, greed, and cultural justification. On the following Friday, Tolstoy finally made his journey to the Tula slaughterhouse. He invited a sportsman friend to join him. The friend, who routinely shot birds and animals for fun, refused to step inside. The paradox was clear. People wanted to consume the flesh, but they could not bear to look at the violence that put it on their tables.
Tolstoy went on to describe the grim abattoir in harrowing detail, laying bare the moral cost of a society fed on slaughter. For him, the slow adoption of vegetarianism was not a sign of failure but a reflection of the agonizingly gradual nature of human evolution. Moral progress is always slow. However, the true indicator of progress is that it never stops, and it inevitably gathers speed over time. By taking that first step, Tolstoy challenged his readers to align their daily habits with their deepest moral convictions.
Bibliographic Information
- Title: Sins of the Flesh
- Subtitle: A History of Ethical Vegetarian Thought
- Author: Rod Preece (1939–2021)
- Publisher: UBC Press (University of British Columbia Press)
- Publication Year: 2008
- Edition: First Edition
- ISBN: 978-0-7748-1509-3 (bound); 978-0-7748-1510-9 (pbk.)
- Historical Period Covered: Prehistory to the late 20th and early 21st centuries
- Main Subject Areas: Animal Ethics, History of Vegetarianism, Intellectual History, Environmental Philosophy, Comparative Religion, History of Science and Medicine
[p. 287-289]